Need to feed a crowd? Then you NEED a potato bar with the best toppings! Whether you’re offering baked potatoes, mashed potatoes, or even sweet potatoes, we’ve the ultimate list of potato bar ideas!
Potato Bar Ideas
Potato Bar Item Essential 01: Potatoes!
It’s essential to start your potato bar with bakes potatoes! Bake them wrapped in foil in the oven and they will stay warm for quite a while. If you need to keep them warm for a few hours, fill a cooler with hot water, let it sit for 15 minutes, then dry it and put the potatoes inside. This works for regular potatoes and sweet potatoes as well!
For a fun take on this classic, include mashed potatoes with your baked potatoes. These are definitely easier for kids to navigate than the traditional baked potatoes and will cut down on the mess.
Potato Bar Essential Item 02: Basics
If you’re going for some solid basics, you have to have salt, pepper, butter, and sour cream. These basics will please even the picky eaters! As a bonus, they also make a great base for the other toppings on this list.
Potato Bar Essential Item 03: Cheese!
Cheese is an essential topping for a potato bar. Try providing a few different types of cheese like shredded, cubed, or liquid. Also, make sure to vary your flavor profiles. Cheddar is a sure hit with most crowds, but what about spicy queso or crumbled blue cheese? They add a punch of flavor to a boring spud. Try melting your cheese in a fondue pot for an additional twist on a classic!
Potato Bar Essential Item 04: We Got the Meat!
This is a classic that is perfect with potatoes and a great way to sneak in some protein. Check out our favorite recipe here. It tops baked potatoes perfectly!
If you have a house full of Taco Tuesday lovers, having good taco meat around to top your potatoes is a must. The potatoes have a mild flavor, so adding something with a kick makes a perfect pairing.
Bacon is the ultimate baked potato bar food! It works well with almost every other topping because it’s bacon. To make large batches of bacon without over-crowding your stove, try baking the bacon in the oven. You can get perfectly crispy bacon every time with a quick clean up to boot.
Potato Bar Essential Item 04: Veggies
To round out your potato bar, you’ve got to have some good veggies ready to go. Broccoli works awesome when paired with cheese! It adds color and nutrients, and if you stage it juuuust right, you might just be able to sneak it into your toddler’s potatoes without them noticing.
Your crew won’t go for broccoli? Then try salsa! Salsa is a topping that works awesome on so many levels. You can layer it with meat and cheese and create a delicious main dish.
Potato Bar Essential Item 06: Sauce
Whether you opt for gravy, alfredo, or ranch, you can’t go wrong with having multiple sauces for your potato bar! Having something creamy to put on top of your spicy salsa or perfectly seasoned chili will make your taco bar the best on the block. Grab a set of these serving bottles to make topping the potatoes almost mess-free.
The moral of this story is that potato bars are boss. You can feed a group and cater to individual tastes with ease! From baked to mashed or sweet, the potato is a perfect blank canvas. Happy Hosting!